Home Blog Page 1068

EU Gears Up Retaliation Plans Against US Tariff

0

The European Union is gearing up set of possible counter-measures against the United States as prospects for an acceptable trade agreement with Washington fade, according to EU diplomats.

An increasing number of EU members, including Germany, are now considering using wide-ranging “anti-coercion” measures which would let the bloc target U.S. services or curb access to public tenders in the absence of a deal, diplomats say.

The European Commission, which negotiates trade agreements on behalf of the 27-member bloc, had appeared on course for a agreement in which the EU would still have faced a 10% U.S. tariff on most of its exports, with some concessions.

Such hopes now seem dashed after President Donald Trump’s threat to impose a 30% tariff by August 1, and following talks between EU Trade Commissioner Maros Sefcovic and U.S. counterparts in Washington last week.

Sefcovic, who has said a 30% tariff would “practically prohibit” transatlantic trade, delivered a sober report on the current state of play to EU envoys on Friday, diplomats told Reuters.

U.S. counterparts had come up with diverging solutions during his meetings, including a baseline rate that could be well above 10%, the EU diplomats added.

“Each interlocutor seemed to have different ideas. No one can tell (Sefcovic) what would actually fly with Trump,” one diplomat said.

Prospects of easing or removing 50% U.S. tariffs on steel and aluminium and 25% on cars and car parts appear limited.

‘Nuclear Option’

Washington has also rejected the EU’s demand for a “standstill” arrangement, whereby no further tariffs would be imposed after a deal is struck. The rationale, according to diplomats, is that Trump’s hands cannot be tied on national security, the basis of Section 232 trade investigations into pharmaceuticals, semiconductors and timber.

Accordingly, the mood has pivoted among EU countries, EU diplomats say, and they are more ready to react, even though a negotiated solution is their preferred option.

The EU has one package of tariffs on 21 billion euros ($24.5 billion) of U.S. goods that is currently suspended until August 6. The bloc must still decide on a further set of countermeasures on 72 billion euros of U.S. exports.

Discussions have also increased on using the EU’s wide-ranging “anti-coercion” instrument (ACI) that allows the bloc to retaliate against third countries that put economic pressure on member states to change their policies.

 

 

 

Source:Reuters/Ejiofor Ezeifeoma

Academic Body COEASU Commends TETFund For Exceptional Performance 

The President of the Colleges of Education Academic Staff Union (COEASU), Dr. Smart Olugbeko, has commended the Tertiary Education Trust Fund (TETFund) for its exceptional performance under the leadership of Arc. Sonny Echono.

Dr. Olugbeko made the remarks while addressing a group of Nigerian students from Colleges of Education who paid a courtesy visit to the COEASU leadership in Abuja, Nigeria

The students, who represented various institutions across the country, had come to thank the leadership of the Union for its giant roles towards Federal government’s approval of the Dual Mandate for Colleges of Education, which grants Colleges of Education degree-awarding status.

The students’ spokesperson, Comrade Ahmed Akande, commended the COEASU leadership for its efforts in ensuring the realisation of the Dual Mandate in Colleges of Education.

However, he also charged the leadership of the Union to ensure that the Federal government pays students on teaching practice monthly stipends, just like their counterparts in Engineering and Medicine who receive stipends during industrial attachment or housemanship.

On the degree awarding status for Colleges of Education, Dr. Olugbeko asked the students to appreciate the President, His Excellency, Asiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu, for signing into law the bill that grants degree awarding status to Colleges of Education and for the president’s positive disposition towards payment of teaching practice stipend to students and lecturers.

Dr. Olugbeko revealed that the implementation is being worked out by the Federal Government while TETFund has been identified as a critical stakeholder in the implementation.

“The involvement of TETFund in the implementation process of the Teaching Practice stipend is a guarantee of its successful execution. TETFund under the leadership of Arc. Sonny Echono has transformed into a beacon of excellence in public service, and the major source of running public tertiary institutions in Nigeria.

“We are proud to associate with the Fund. We have every confidence that TETFund will bring its characteristic efficiency and transparency to the process of the implementation of the disbursement of the stipends when the time comes,” Dr. Olugbeko said

According to Dr. Olugbeko, “TETFund handles huge sum of money every year and has been very transparent in the disbursement of the funds to tertiary institutions.

“It is one organisation that is not afraid of inviting the academic staff unions: COEASU, ASUU and ASUP to be involved in the monitoring of its activities when many organisations become hypertensive whenever they see the unions. The unions have been able to provide critical feedback to the TETFund which has reflected in the efficiency of its operations.

“Thus, TETFund has transformed into one of the best-run government institutions in Nigeria, demonstrating remarkable focus, transparency, and proactiveness. The Fund’s commitment to supporting tertiary education in Nigeria is laudable, and its impact is being felt across the country, and it is in the recognition of this that the Federal government considered TETFund as a critical stakeholder in its implementation”.

The President of COEASU also commended the Honourable Minister of Education, Dr. Tunji Alausa, for his transformative activities in the Ministry, stressing that since his assumption of office, the Minister has been working tirelessly to ensure Nigeria’s education sector is well-positioned for greatness.

Dr. Olugbeko specifically praised the Minister for his support towards the implementation of the Dual Mandate in Colleges of Education, which has been a game-changer for teacher education in Nigeria.

The COEASU President thanked the students for their visit and reaffirmed the Union’s commitment to supporting their welfare and interests. He assured them that COEASU would continue to work tirelessly to ensure that their concerns are addressed and their needs are met.

“We are committed to supporting the development of tertiary education in Nigeria, and we will continue to work with all stakeholders to achieve this goal,” Dr. Olugbeko said.

Dr. Olugbeko charged the students to shun evil acts and remain good ambassadors of their institutions, adding that as teachers in training, they must demonstrate the good qualities of teachers in all their endeavours.

 

Olusola Akintonde

Group Demand Establishment of Police Pension Board In Ilorin

A group of retired police officers under the banner of the Association of Retired Police Officers of Nigeria (ARPON), Kwara State Chapter, North Central Nigeria staged a peaceful protest in Ilorin on Monday, demanding the immediate establishment of a Police Pension Board to independently manage the pension affairs of officers of the Nigeria Police Force.

The protesters, who marched to the Press Centre of the Nigeria Union of Journalists (NUJ), Kwara State Council, lamented what they described as years of suffering under the Contributory Pension Scheme (CPS), which they said has failed to cater adequately for the welfare of retired police personnel.

Holding placards with bold messages such as “Establish Police Pension Board Now!”, “We Deserve Better After 35 Years of Service!”, and “If CPS is Fair, Why Did Top Police Brass Exit?”,the retired officers called on President Bola Ahmed Tinubu, the National Assembly, and the Inspector General of Police to intervene urgently by removing police retirees from the CPS and creating a dedicated pension board for the force, akin to what is obtainable in other security agencies.

Chairman of the association in the State, retired Chief Superintendent of Police Yakubu Jimoh, said the demand is long overdue.

He urged the federal government to heed their call and implement legislative action to exit police retirees from the contributory scheme and establish a Police Pension Board that will ensure justice and fairness in the management of pensions.

“We are not asking for too much,” Jimoh said. “Our colleagues in the military and DSS are already out of this scheme and enjoy better pension packages. We, who risked our lives to maintain law and order for over three decades, deserve no less. A Police Pension Board should be created immediately to oversee our pension matters.”

He also demanded the release of the report from the Senate Committee on Establishment and Public Services on the bill proposing the creation of the board, which has been pending since the public hearing in November 2024.

Furthermore, he called for expedited disbursement of the N758 billion pension shortfall owed security agencies, noting that June 2025 had earlier been announced as the proposed date for payment.

“We are told the money is coming next year, but how many of us will still be alive by then?” he asked rhetorically. “The longer we wait, the more our members suffer and die without benefitting from what they’ve earned.”

Jimoh decried the injustice of junior officers receiving meager gratuities and monthly stipends despite dedicating their entire careers to national service.

He cited the case of a retired Superintendent of Police receiving just N2.4 million as gratuity and N30,000 monthly pension.

In a jointly signed letter presented to journalists, ARPON members questioned why only top police brass—Inspector Generals, Deputy Inspector Generals, and Assistant Inspector General have been exempted from the CPS while lower-ranking officers continue to suffer.

“Where are we exiting to?” Jimoh said. “We want to go where our police generals have gone. We all served this country. Why the discrimination?”

Legal Adviser of the association, retired Superintendent of Police Adekunle Iwalaiye, added emotional weight to the protest, emphasizing the inhumane treatment retired officers face due to the inefficiencies of the contributory scheme.

“After 35 years of meritorious service, what we get is far from a living wage,” he said. “Many of us sustained injuries in the line of duty, some carry permanent bullet wounds. We have sacrificed our youth for Nigeria. All we ask is to be treated with dignity.” he stressed.

Iwalaiye noted that many retired officers receive pensions below N50,000, a sum he said cannot even purchase a bag of rice. He said this financial hardship has exposed their families to untold suffering and led to the premature deaths of many retirees due to lack of access to healthcare.

“We are not criminals, we are not violent,” he said. “We simply want to live in retirement with dignity and peace of mind. Establishing a Police Pension Board is the way forward.” he added.

The protesters vowed to sustain their agitation until the federal government establishes the proposed Police Pension Board and exits all police retirees from the Contributory Pension Scheme.

 

Olusola Akintonde

Orumba South Constructs Erosion System, Empowers Farmers And Youths

The Chairman of Orumba South Local Government Area in Anambra State, Hon. Shedrack Azubuike, has commissioned a 220-meter erosion control project in Okukoro Ajaekpe as part of his administration’s efforts to mitigate environmental degradation in the region.

Announcing this during a recent community engagement campaign, Hon. Azubuike highlighted the project as a key intervention under his one-year stewardship, aimed at safeguarding local infrastructure and farmland from erosion threats.

In addition to erosion control, the council distributed over 9,000 yam seedlings, cassava cuttings, and 4,000 units of improved maize seeds to farmers across the LGA, supporting agricultural productivity and food security.

Azubuike also unveiled a series of development initiatives, including the transformation of Nkwo Triangle into a functional Central Park for commercial transport operators, the commissioning of a modern ICT centre, and the re-equipping of the Amuda Primary Health Centre to enhance healthcare delivery.

Under the auspices of the Nwabugo Empowerment Foundation, the administration has empowered youth through vocational tools and financial grants, including a ₦1 million startup capital awarded to a promising local entrepreneur. Skills development programmes in cybersecurity, tailoring, agriculture, and welding are currently underway.

Azubuike further noted the administration’s ongoing support for education, security enhancement, and the distribution of food palliatives to vulnerable households, underscoring his commitment to holistic community development.

Our administration has executed impactful projects ranging from erosion control and road rehabilitation to youth empowerment and agricultural support,” he said.

With the November 8 gubernatorial election approaching, the council chairman reiterated his support for Governor Chukwuma Soludo’s re-election bid, describing the governor’s leadership as transformational. He emphasized that grassroots mobilization across Orumba South’s 18 wards is in full swing to ensure continued progress.

Governor Soludo deserves our full support to consolidate on the visible progress made in infrastructure, education, health, and economic empowerment across Anambra State,” Azubuike declared.

He concluded by expressing confidence that Orumba South will deliver overwhelming support for Governor Soludo, as the administration continues to engage constituents with its development record and vision for continuity.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Oyenike Oyeniyi 

NITDA, API Push Joint Action on Harmful Online Content

0

In a bid to confront the growing threat of harmful online content, the National Information Technology Development Agency (NITDA), in collaboration with Advocacy for Policy and Innovation (API), hosted a one-day stakeholder workshop in Abuja to advance discussions on the draft Online Harm Protection (OHP) Bill.

READ ALSO: NITDA Champions Gender Inclusion in Nigeria’s AI, Digital Economy

The event gathered a wide range of participants including platform policy leaders, civil society advocates, academics, and government regulators to address pressing issues such as cyberbullying, gender-based violence, disinformation, hate speech, and digital exploitation.

Delivering the keynote address titled “Strengthening Trust and Accountability in Nigeria’s Digital Future,” NITDA Director General Kashifu Inuwa emphasized the need for a fresh regulatory approach that protects users while safeguarding freedom of expression.

The draft bill proposes establishing an Online Safety Council, implementing platform accountability measures, and creating redress mechanisms for victims all within a framework that respects democratic and civic freedoms.

“Today, the biggest question is: to what extent should our lives be directed and controlled by powerful digital systems and under what conditions?” Inuwa asked. “These systems filter what we see, prescribe what we know, and influence what we think, even shaping our decisions during elections. This is unaccountable power in the hands of private individuals.”

He noted that a white paper, developed collaboratively by government, civil society, academia, and the tech industry, was issued in December 2023. “We must move beyond self-regulation by big tech,” he said. “True democratic regulation requires inclusive input and legally binding rules.”

API Co-Founder Victoria Manya also underscored the urgency of legislative action. “The cost of inaction is high. Every day, Nigerians face harassment, exploitation, misinformation, and algorithmic bias. The solution isn’t a moral panic, but a rights-based framework grounded in local realities and informed by global best practices,” she said.

She highlighted that the Online Harm Protection White Paper emerged from months of collaborative consultations and emphasized that the proposed bill is still evolving hence the importance of continued dialogue.

Participants at the workshop commended the transparent and inclusive drafting process, calling for continued openness, inclusion of marginalized voices, and fair, timely redress mechanisms.

Anambra 2025: AA Candidate Calls For Issue-Based Campaigns

Governorship candidate of the Action Alliance (AA) in the upcoming Anambra State election, Ozo Jeff Nweke, has called on fellow contenders to uphold the ethics of political engagement and refrain from blackmail or personal attacks in their quest for power.

Addressing journalists during a weekend press conference in Awka, Nweke urged all candidates to engage the electorate constructively and focus their campaigns on policies and development plans rather than character assassination or mudslinging.

“The essence of political campaigns should not be to malign opponents or engage in needless altercations, but to present our vision and programmes to the people,” Nweke stated.

“We must shift our focus to real issues, security, education, economy, job creation, and governance not name-calling or personal vendettas.”

He emphasised that Anambra citizens deserve mature, issue-based discourse, particularly in a state grappling with rising insecurity, economic strain, and youth unemployment.

“How do you intend to tackle the kidnappings and killings that have become rampant? What’s your strategy for addressing the suffocating multiple taxation affecting our people and businesses? What is your plan for revitalizing education, attracting investors, creating jobs, and growing the revenue base?” Nweke queried.

He warned that any deviation from such constructive engagement amounts to “politics of bitterness” and “playing to the gallery”—a style he believes Anambra has outgrown.

The AA flag bearer also condemned recent online criticisms aimed at Governor Chukwuma Soludo over a viral video showing the governor dancing with his son to a song produced by the latter. Some commentators had accused Soludo of indulging in frivolities amid serious state matters.

Describing the backlash as “distasteful and unnecessary,” Nweke defended the governor’s right to personal expression and family time.

“Governor Soludo is a father and a human being. Dancing with his son is neither immoral nor wrong,” he said. “It is both condemnable and detestable to ridicule the First Family over such a harmless act. We must move away from dirty politics and focus on what truly matters to the people.”

Nweke also outlined the Action Alliance’s commitment to a solution-driven, people-focused campaign. He said his party is presenting a clear roadmap to “rescue Anambra from years of misgovernance” and place the state on a sustainable development trajectory.

“We have mapped out robust programmes to address the core challenges confronting our state. These plans continue to unfold as we meet with communities across Anambra. Our approach is inclusive, practical, and grounded in the needs of our people,” he said.

While acknowledging that no administration is without flaws, Nweke said political criticism should be constructive.

HOPE Programme: Nigerian Government Inaugurates Inter-Ministerial Committee 

The Nigerian Government has inaugurated an Inter-Ministerial Committee for the Human Capital Opportunities for Prosperity and Equity (HOPE) program to ensure improved service delivery in the areas of education, health care services and good governance for the benefit of Nigerians.

The Inter-Ministerial Committee chaired by the Minister of Budget and Economic Planning Senator Abubakar Bagudu and co-chaired by the Ministers of Finance and Coordinating Minister of the Economy, Coordinating Minister of Health and Social Welfare, Education and Women Affairs respectively, have the following terms of reference:

· Assess the programmes’s implementation progress and the achievements of Disbursement Linked Indicators (DLIs) across all beneficiary entities;

· Evaluate disbursement statuses to the implementing agencies and the Investment Programme Financing (IPF) implementations;

· Review the HOPE series of operations Vis a viz national priorities, Monitoring and Evaluation strategy, communication activities, including publishing APA results;

· Examine the progress of the capacity building programme across implementing agencies;

· Tackle any risks and challenges that may impact programme implementation.

Sen. Bagudu while inaugurating the committee reiterated that the Ministry only coordinates the implementation of National Development Plans of the Federal Government and the aim of inaugurating the committee was to develop a road map and ensure a seamless implementation of the HOPE programme by the concerned Ministries. He noted, “we are not competing, we are complimenting each other to drive the HOPE project”

The steering committee is being coordinated by the Federal Ministry of Budget and Economic Planning through the HOPE Governance national Programme Coordinating Unit (NCPU) which will also serve as the Secretariat of the HOPE programme. The National Coordinator of HOPE-Governance is Dr. Assad Hassan.

The HOPE-Governance NCPU will work in collaboration with the Ministries of Health and Social Welfare, Education and Finance at the federal level and their counterparts at the State and local levels to implement the Programme.

The Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister of the Economy Mr. Adebayo Olawale Edun, the Coordinating Minister of Health and Social Welfare Prof. Muhammad Ali Pate, Minister of Education Dr. Tunji Alausa and the Minister of Women Affairs Hajia Imaan Suleiman- Ibrahim Fsi were at the meeting and promised their unalloyed support in the implementation of the HOPE programme.

The Ministers noted that the economic reforms of President Bola Ahmed Tinubu were aimed at human capital development and lifting several Nigerians out of poverty.

Earlier, the Acting Permanent Secretary in his opening remarks, said the overarching objectives of the HOPE project established by the World Bank, was to support the federal government to improve essential services and ensure long term national development.

 

Olusola Akintonde

Exclusive: Meta, X, LinkedIn Challenge Italy’s Unprecedented VAT Demand

0

American tech giants Meta, X, and LinkedIn have filed an appeal challenging a landmark value-added tax (VAT) demand by Italian authorities a case that could set a precedent for tax policy across the European Union, according to four sources familiar with the matter. This marks the first instance in which Italy has failed to reach a settlement in such cases, leading to a full scale judicial tax trial against the companies.

READ ALSO: Meta Appoints Arun Srinivas As India Head

According to the sources, the case escalated because it moved beyond negotiating a settlement amount and instead aimed to set a broader legal precedent regarding how social media platforms deliver their services. Italian tax authorities contend that free user sign-ups on platforms like X, LinkedIn, and Meta constitute taxable transactions, arguing that users effectively exchange their personal data for access to membership accounts.

The matter is particularly delicate amid broader trade tensions between the European Union and the administration of U.S. President Donald Trump. Italy is demanding €887.6 million ($1.03 billion) from Meta, €12.5 million from X, and approximately €140 million from LinkedIn. Meta parent company of Facebook and Instagram Elon Musk’s X, and Microsoft-owned LinkedIn submitted their appeals to a first-instance tax court shortly after mid July, following the expiration of the deadline to respond to a tax assessment notice issued by Italy’s Revenue Agency in March.

According to several experts consulted by Reuters, the Italian approach could affect almost all companies, from airlines to supermarkets to publishers, who link access to free services on their sites to users’ acceptance of profiling cookies.

It could also eventually be extended across the EU where VAT is a harmonised tax.

In a statement to Reuters, Meta said that it had cooperated “fully with the authorities on our obligations under EU and local law”.

It added that the company “strongly disagrees with the idea that providing access to online platforms to users should be subject to VAT”.

LinkedIn said it had “nothing to share at this time”.

X did not respond to a request for comment from Reuters.

ROME SEEN SEEKING EU ADVISORY

It is uncertain whether a full trial of the matter, which involves three levels of judgement and takes an average of 10 years, will go ahead.

Following discussions with the three companies, Italy is preparing as a next step to seek an advisory opinion from the European Commission, the sources said.

The Italian Revenue Agency will have to prepare specific questions, which the Economy Ministry will then send to the EU Commission’s VAT Committee, which meets twice a year.

Rome aims to submit its questions for the meeting scheduled to be held by early November, in order to receive the EU’s comments in time for the following meeting in spring 2026.

Italy’s Economy Ministry and Revenue Agency declined to comment.

The EU Commission’s VAT Committee is an independent advisory group. While its assessment will be non-binding, a “No” could prompt Italy to halt the case and ultimately drop the criminal investigation by Italian prosecutors, according to the sources.

The dispute is one of several between Europeans and U.S. Big Tech.

On July 11 Reuters exclusively reported that Meta would not be tweaking its pay-or-consent model further despite the risk of EU fines.

According to a Financial Times report on July 17, the European Commission has stalled one of its investigations into Musk’s platform X for breaching its digital transparency rules while it seeks to conclude trade talks with the U.S.

($1 = 0.8588 euros)

Microsoft Server Hack Likely Solo Actor, Thousands at Risk

0

A widespread cyberattack targeting Microsoft’s (MSFT.O) server software used by thousands of government agencies and businesses for internal document sharing was likely orchestrated by a single actor, a cybersecurity researcher said on Monday. Microsoft issued an alert on Saturday warning of “active attacks” on on-premise SharePoint servers. The company clarified that SharePoint Online, part of the Microsoft 365 cloud suite, was not affected by the exploit, which is considered a “zero-day” vulnerability due to its previously undiscovered nature.

READ ALSO: Premier League Forms Five-Year AI Partnership With Microsoft

“Based on the consistency of the tradecraft seen across observed attacks, the campaign launched on Friday appears to be a single actor. However, it’s possible that this will quickly change,” Rafe Pilling, Director of Threat Intelligence at Sophos, a British cybersecurity firm.

That tradecraft included the sending of the same digital payload to multiple targets, Pilling added.

Microsoft said it had “provided security updates and encourages customers to install them,” a company spokesperson said in an emailed statement.

It was not clear who was behind the ongoing hack. The FBI said on Sunday it was aware of the attacks and was working closely with its federal and private-sector partners, but offered no other details. Britain’s National Cyber Security Centre did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The Washington Post said unidentified actors in the past few days had exploited a flaw to launch an attack that targeted U.S. and international agencies and businesses. According to data from Shodan, a search engine that helps to identify internet-linked equipment, over 8,000 servers online could theoretically have already been compromised by hackers.

Those servers include major industrial firms, banks, auditors, healthcare companies, and several U.S. state-level and international government entities.

“The SharePoint incident appears to have created a broad level of compromise across a range of servers globally,” said Daniel Card of British cybersecurity consultancy, PwnDefend.

“Taking an assumed breach approach is wise, and it’s also important to understand that just applying the patch isn’t all that is required here.”

Meta Investor Settlement with Zuckerberg Eases Pressure on Delaware Courts

0

A last-minute settlement between Meta Platforms (META.O) shareholders and company leadership last week averted an $8 billion trial and spared CEO Mark Zuckerberg from testifying over alleged misuse of Facebook users’ data. The agreement also eased pressure on the state of Delaware, which has faced mounting criticism from tech and business leaders. The deal was announced by the shareholders’ legal team just as the second day of the eight-day trial in Delaware’s Court of Chancery was set to begin on Thursday.

While the terms are still being finalized, the settlement concludes a case that threatened to accelerate a growing movement of companies leaving Delaware as their legal base. Since last year, Elon Musk and other business leaders have criticized the state’s courts once a major draw for corporate incorporation for decisions they claim make it easier for shareholders to sue company directors. Musk has urged firms to exit Delaware, and over the past year, major public companies including Dropbox (DBX.O), Trump Media & Technology (DJT.O), Roblox (RBLX.N), and Simon Property Group (SPG.N) have reincorporated elsewhere a trend now referred to as “Dexit.”

Critics argue that Delaware’s courts show bias against company founders and awkward context for the Meta case, which named 11 high-profile defendants including billionaires Mark Zuckerberg, Sheryl Sandberg, Marc Andreessen, Palantir co-founder Peter Thiel, and Netflix co-founder Reed Hastings. A ruling in favor of the defendants might have appeared as if the court succumbed to pressure to protect them, while a decision siding with the plaintiffs could have intensified calls for companies to abandon Delaware as their legal base.

“It was going to be really awkward for the court,” said Ann Lipton, a professor at Colorado Law School.

READ ALSO: Social media outage: Mark Zuckerberg loses $7billion

Meta which owns Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp along with attorneys representing both the company’s investors and the defendants, declined to comment.

Shareholder plaintiffs accused current and former Facebook executives and board members of failing to safeguard user data. They asked the court to require the defendants to personally repay the company for $8 billion in legal expenses tied to privacy violations, including a $5 billion fine paid to the Federal Trade Commission in 2019.

The case drew renewed attention to Delaware’s judiciary and Chancellor Kathaleen McCormick, the judge presiding over the matter. McCormick rose to national prominence last year after voiding Elon Musk’s $56 billion Tesla (TSLA.O) compensation package a decision that is currently under appeal.

Adding to the heightened scrutiny, venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz announced earlier this month that it was relocating its incorporation from Delaware to Nevada, urging other companies to do the same. In a blog post, the firm cited concerns that “Delaware courts can at times appear biased against technology startup founders and their boards,” referencing McCormick’s Tesla ruling. The firm did not respond to requests for comment.